Protecting Passengers: The Need for Secure-By-Design Ticketing Solutions
- By TEIXEIRA COSTA Ludovic
- In
In this blog, Calypso Technical Expert, Ludovic Teixeira Costa, explores the key developments in cybersecurity and addresses how the changing threat landscape is having a profound impact on transport ticketing.
Digital first solutions are becoming commonplace: from payments to access control to identity, users want easy, direct access to the world through their smartphones. Transport ticketing is no different. And while digital offers new and convenient user experiences, we cannot afford to lose sight of the fact that digital transformation brings new risks.
Cyberattacks and data breaches are catastrophic for multiple victims: the individuals directly affected, and the company who is ultimately held responsible. Within transport ticketing, accountability lies with networks to protect their customers. But they don’t have to do it alone.
Security is one of the foremost concerns of the Calypso Network Association (CNA) member community. Together, industry leaders have contributed to analysing the security and quality of service of ticketing information systems based on Calypso to ensure networks can benefit from robust, secure-by-design solutions. Here are three key trends we’re currently seeing across the cybersecurity space in ticketing:
Ticket fraud is on the rise
Transport ticketing operate with very tight margins. For most public transport operators, profit potential lies in the volume of passengers it is able to serve. This means that robust resistance to fraud is essential to profitability: any erasure of profit margins can tip networks into the red.
In recent years, fraudulent transactions have become more frequent. Memory tickets have rightly faced scrutiny for the ease with which fraudsters are able to manipulate the value stored in the monotonic counter. It was found that these tickets could easily be read and rewritten using readily available technology and without the need of any type of authentication in less than 15 minutes. This meant that the same ticket could be fraudulently used time and time again without alerting the networks security systems.
Its not just the ticketing architecture that’s under attack though. The data carrier connecting tickets and terminals is another point of exchange that bad actors can look to exploit.
The prime example of this issue is Quick Response (QR) Code tickets. While adopted at scale, this roll out has not been systematic. Codes stored on mobile devices benefit from dynamic mechanisms that enhance security, but such protections are not possible on physical paper or plastic tickets. Furthermore, users may find it difficult to distinguish a legitimate QR Code from a fraudulent one. Scanning a malicious QR Code may expose their device to security risks and may also impact transport operators that rely on these technologies for ticket distribution, validation and inspection.
These shortcomings of QR tickets, combined with their slower, less ergonomic user experience, mean that many operators prefer Near Field Communication (NFC) tickets stored either on a smartcard or on the passenger’s device. These too face challenges though. An attacker with sufficient technical experience working against an insufficiently protected system could allow a fraudulent or compromised ticket to be used repeatedly without necessarily triggering the network’s fraud detection mechanisms.
Security can therefore no longer rely solely on the ticket medium or the mobile application. It must be implemented end to end, with consistent security mechanisms across both the terminal and back-end systems, particularly to ensure ticket authenticity, data integrity, transaction freshness, and the detection of abnormal or fraudulent usage.
AI brings never before seen threats
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is arguably one of the most disruptive innovations across the entire technology landscape. Its applications are developing rapidly, and the transport sector is no exception. Transport networks can use AI to optimise service planning, account for changing weather or traffic conditions, and improve capacity management.
However, the same technologies can also be used to significantly increase the scale and automation of attacks. AI’s ability to rapidly process large amounts of data, identify patterns, and automate certain tasks may enable fraudsters to accelerate the analysis and exploitation of weaknesses in digital ticketing solutions.
This presents a unique challenge for transport systems. Legacy memory tickets that feature weak cryptographic keys or poorly implemented monotonic counters are ripe for brute force attacks, and so techniques that previously required specialised knowledge and significant manual intervention could therefore become faster, more accessible and more easily repeatable using automated AI.
The challenge is therefore no longer limited to protecting the system against individual attempts at fraud. Ticketing systems must also be capable of detecting and mitigating automated attacks that can be executed rapidly and at scale.
The reproduction and modification or fraudulent use of transport tickets, could become increasingly automated and carried out on a much larger scale.
The challenge is therefore no longer limited to protecting the system against individual attempts at fraud. Ticketing systems must also be capable of detecting and mitigating automated attacks that can be executed rapidly and at scale.
In this evolving threat landscape, security must be considered a fundamental part of the ticketing system architecture. Transport networks must implement a defence-in-depth approach that covers the entire trust chain from the passenger’s ticket medium right through to back-end systems. Ticket authenticity, data integrity, protection against reproduction, and detection of abnormal or fraudulent usage must all be monitored and addressed consistently to withstand increasingly automated, sophisticated threats.
Cybersecurity Frameworks and the Cyber Resilience Act
An evolving threat landscape brings with it a corresponding change to regulatory requirements. In the European Union (EU), the 2024 Cyber Resilience Act introduced new, mandated “security by design” requirements for both hardware and software, including a requirement for manufacturers to provide regular security updates for their products.
Meanwhile in the United States, the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 has been designed to create a more comprehensive, integrated approach to cybersecurity. It demands that organisations take proactive ownership of their cybersecurity through real time fraud monitoring and routine systems testing to ensure compliance.
Ticketing systems need stronger security by design
The Calypso Standard is designed to protect members from this fast-evolving threat landscape. Designed by industry leading experts based on the precise requirements shared by members of the CNA community, Calypso Specifications are routinely updated to align with the latest available security standards and mitigate emerging threats. This has provided state of the art resilience to ticketing systems for over 25 years and zero hacks is a source of great pride to our engineers.
Calypso Open Standards, developed for the mobility community and by the mobility community, give operators the flexibility to develop and master a sovereign system that meets their needs, safe in the knowledge that security is of the highest level.
To ensure that Calypso cards are secure, but also seamlessly interoperable at the contactless protocol level, we have published a list of all approved cards.
